Skip to content
Urban Spins

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: The Baroque Master’s Dynamic Mary Magdalene.

A female figure tilts her head backwards. Lids sealed, her mouth is closed, yet she is awake and aware. Sporting warm cheeks and crimson lips, her long golden hair catches the light from a single flame, bathed in a luminous glow in an predominantly gloomy space. Her attire includes a lace-trimmed blouse—falling off one shoulder to expose alabaster skin—to a heavy yellow and purple cloth. She appears by herself, oblivious of any observer, existing in a state of sublime freedom.

A Significant New Purchase

The woman is Mary Magdalene depicted in ecstasy, painted in the 1620s by the renowned painter Artemisia. Recently acquired by the prestigious institution in the U.S. capital, it is set to go on public view from late February. This marks the institution’s first purchase of a work by Gentileschi, and curator Letizia Treves has written that it portrays the saint as “neither repentant nor suffering”. This is an important difference, for generations, her depiction has been crafted not only by biblical text but fabulated and blurred by powerful male figures.

“The most adaptable female figure in religious painting,” according to a expert stated.

Examine portrayals of her and you will see a thinker, preacher, follower, and witness; weeping at the foot of the Cross, washing Christ’s feet, or gazing heavenward—often atoning with shimmering tears and, too often, revealing her bosom. At times identified by a alabaster jar or a crimson garment—unlike the Virgin Mary’s azure—she is most popularly known nowadays as a prostitute, despite not a single biblical verse labeling her as such.

Unraveling the Historical Figure

“In reality, we do not truly know who she was,” noted the scholar. “So all these strata of meaning have fallen upon her. The shifts she undergoes, both visually but narratively, devotionally, theologically, are as closely related to cultural attitudes and theological shifts as they are to faith.” So what do we know?

She appears in the New Testament 12 times. The first, she has evil spirits cast out from her; the rest, she is present at Christ’s crucifixion and is the primary person to see his rising. It is she who proclaims the “good news”. The sexual and immoral reputation can mostly be linked to a sermon delivered in the 500s by Gregory I, who confused her with another Mary and an anonymous woman who bathed Jesus’s feet with her tears.

By lumping them together, Pope Gregory effectively “invented” the penitent prostitute—a myth further expanded by subsequent theologians and medieval legends. Painters and sculptors followed suit, and in a predominantly illiterate but visually literate world, this was highly impactful. Her “evil spirits” became the “cardinal vices”, establishing her dominant narrative as one of sexual fall and later redemption—solidified in artistic renderings that continue to shape beliefs today.

A Legacy of Suffering and Sexualization

Consider Donatello’s emaciated, wooden Magdalene clasping her hands in penance, to another master’s 1606 portrayal of her devoid of life and near death—alongside Rubens’ semi-nude, rapturous Magdalene supported by angels. Mary Magdalene has frequently been denigrated sexually. One artist’s engraving presented her demurely, with cascading hair draping her unclothed body, while Titian’s version looks upward, with tearful eyes and carefully placed hands exposing her breasts.

It seems, anguish and sexualization were the dominant extremes in her depiction: she could act as a cautionary tale against sin, be the exemplar for repentance, while providing artists a excuse to paint the female form masked as piety. The “fallen woman redeemed” narrative persisted for centuries—so profoundly that institutions called “Magdalene laundries” subjected women into exploitative labor, systems that shockingly only closed a mere 30 years ago.

A Radical Reimagining

However, consider if there was a different facet to her narrative? What if her tale could be one of enlightenment and metamorphosis, where she was pictured as full of life, delight, and sublimity? In other words, what if we viewed her through the eyes of a female artist?

That is what Gentileschi accomplishes. Her portrait is not posing for the audience; she is not weeping, not penitent, without shame, not objectified, and not preaching a sermon. Instead, she has rosy cheeks and is, as described, “passionately alive … in the grip of divine joy”. An expert remarked that Gentileschi “imbues Mary Magdalene with an dynamic vitality”.

“Yes, it’s an ecstasy painting, but it’s not her instant of repentance. It’s a moment of divine meeting … described at times as if it’s the finest physical experience … the greatest orgasm she could ever have. It’s beautiful, it’s physical, it’s sensual, it’s transcendent. You are lifted outside yourself to a higher level.”

Often, when women portray biblical or mythological women, they show them not as passive, guilty, shameful, or subordinate, but as active, multifaceted, and with minds of their own: “Women with a capital ‘W’”.

A Greater Shift Towards Equality

Thus, while this recent Gentileschi may ultimately be redressing a representational imbalance at the gallery, its importance extends further. It alters not only how we view biblical and archetypal women, but also the female experience at large.

This view is one the Church eventually recognized. In 1969, it officially recognized her canonical definition as a faithful follower rather than a penitent sinner. More recently 2016, Pope Francis elevated her status to “apostle to the apostles”, marking 22 July as her celebration. This indicates that, as establishments change, viewpoints are shifting. This acquisition—portraying a figure liberated from a patriarchal gaze, living for herself, not suffering nor sensationalised—is part of a larger shift towards equality.

Written by

Jennifer Stewart

Elara is a cultural journalist and music enthusiast who documents urban trends and underground scenes across North America.

Urban Spins

Type to search articles.